Slightly OT: Will upgrading to Vista break affect VS 2005 negatively?

Slightly OT: Will upgrading to Vista break affect VS 2005 negatively?

Old forum URL: forums.lhotka.net/forums/t/2087.aspx


ChrisD posted on Saturday, January 06, 2007

Happy New Year guys :)

I am considering upgrading my PC to Vista but I have a number of questions and I wonder if anyone out there has any experience of using it and could give me answers?

A) I currently have a Windows XP SP2 PC with a dual core processor and 2 Gb of Ram so I think it's high enough spec.  It has my development environment installed on it and working.  If I ran a VISTA upgrade into my box to go from XP SP2 --> Vista would the current VS2005 and SQL Server 2005 installs be damaged in any way?

B) Is VS 2005 fully tested with Vista?  Is anything that works on SP2 now likely to stop working if I were to upgrade?

C) What version of Vista does a developer using VS 2005 need?  Do we have to go all the way to Ultimate or is one of the Business editions good enough?

D) Are there any other nasty problems that I would need to know about before embarking on this upgrade?

E) Most importantly of all; does Vista have any snagging issues that will stop CSLA.net from working?

Thanks very much for bothering to read this; I know that Vista isn't out properly yet , and so folk may not be able to answer this but any feedback would be very gratefully received.

Cheers

ChrisD

ChrisD replied on Saturday, January 06, 2007

I've just ran the Vista Upgrade advisor and has pointed out several packages that "might" not work after a Vista upgrade e.g. Norton Antivirus a couple of games etc.  It didn't seem to suggest that VS itself was in any danger of failing.

This does make me feel a little unsure of whether an upgrade is the best way to go though.

Any feedback on the questions above gratefully received :)

ChrisD

Jurjen replied on Sunday, January 07, 2007

Chris,

If I were you I'd use some app like Ghost or Drive Image to create a backup so you could fall back from Vista to your current XP SP2 installation.
Best of luck, let us know how you progress with running VS2005 on Windows Vista

Jurjen.

ChrisD replied on Monday, January 08, 2007

Hi Jurjen,

I coudn't agree more :)  I doubt i'll be rushing into this but i have to admit I'm a bit intrigued to see Vista as I haven't really seen it in action yet.

This isn't really a high priority for me as my current box works really well and i'm sadly not getting any work that would use CSLA or even .NET at the moment... what a waste :(

Cheers

Chris

JoeFallon1 replied on Monday, January 08, 2007

Chris,

I am very much under the impression that VS does not work well with Vista yet. I would definitely wait until "VS 2005 SP1 For Vista" comes out in a month or 2. MS released VS2005 SP1 for older platforms already because the alternative would be to make everyone else wait just for the Vista upgrade bits which most people don't want yet anyway.

Joe

 

Izhido replied on Monday, January 08, 2007

Hi!
I'm sorry to inform you that, if you try to upgrade your machine as it is right now, your SQL Server will not work anymore, unless you apply the (still non-existing) SP2 to it:

http://www.microsoft.com/sql/howtobuy/sqlonvista.mspx

As for the other tools, when I had the Betas on my machine, most things worked, but slooooooowly. Not sure for this new release.

- Izhido

Thunderstruck replied on Monday, January 08, 2007

I have a co-worker who has been messing with Vista for quite some time, and VS2005 will definately not work with it.  As JoeFallon1 said, there is a patch coming out that fixes this issue.

Curelom replied on Tuesday, January 09, 2007

Not work?  I have been running VS2005 and CSLA on Vista for about a month now and haven't had any issues once I was able to get it running in the first place.  First off, make sure you install SP1.  There is also a Vista SP1 beta for VS2005, but I haven't seen any difference to using that or not at all.  The real trick is that you need to run VS2005 in admin mode.  This can be done by either right clicking and Run as Administrator, or for a more permanent solution, go to the properties of devenv.exe, click the compatibility tab and click the "Run this program as an administrator"

I don't use every bit of VS2005, so I can't verify that EVERYTHING works.  Just everything I have tried which is quite a bit.

cmellon replied on Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Hi,

I too have Vista 64 Bit installed and VS2005 runs ok, not had any issues as yet.

I'll let you know if I encounter any, only been using for last couple of weeks and haven;t done much development on it as of yet apart from fired up a couple of projects to make sure they still worked.

(I did read somewhere about some issues with IIS thats build into Vista.  Can;t remember where the post was, might be worth doing a search on the forum for Vista see what comes up if you have't already done so)

Regards

Craig

Curelom replied on Wednesday, January 10, 2007

I had forgotten about IIS.  Yes it had a few issues.  To fix most of them you have to go into the "Turn Windows features On and Off" and go into iis and make sure you check all of the IIS 6 stuff.  It isn't installed by default.  Once this is installed the only issue I have is everytime I open a website in VS2005, it tells me that the website isn't configured for .Net 2.0 and asks me to config it as such.  I just click yes, and everything works fine.

Also, IIS 7.0 has had steeper learning curve then I would have expected, but that's completely unrelated.

Copyright (c) Marimer LLC