ASP.NET membership roles v/s CSLA auth/authrorization

atlanta posted on Monday, February 05, 2007

    Hi,

We need to do authentication and authorization with data defined in an Oracle database.

We are going to use CSLA.NET.
I read the CSLA custom authentication and authorization. I am bit confused whether to use custom ASP.NET membership providers or CSLA method.

If anybody has experience and have see one better than the other please share.

Thanks,

atlanta replied on Monday, February 05, 2007

  I think I got this too.

The PTMembershipProvider in the sample explains what I was trying to clear.

Thanks,

JoeFallon1 replied on Tuesday, February 06, 2007

I use a custom scheme.

I have a table of users and roles and permissions.

My custom Principal class gathers all the data upon log in and then uses it in various places when needed.

Joe

 

tsaltd replied on Thursday, February 15, 2007

This seems to be the most recent thread on the subject .... I've searched the forum archives and have found some sophisticated discussions on the issue, but I'd sure like to see a version of PTWeb that uses the ASP.Net 2.0 Membership framework.

Does anyone have any ( prefereably C# ) code to share that illustrates how this works in a basic scenario ?

(Remote data portal issues are interesting, but I want to get the basics down first ).

Thanks,

Steve